The Ashwagandha Paradox: When Your Anxiety Supplement Causes Restlessness

Understanding Why This Popular Adaptogen Sometimes Backfires

You started taking ashwagandha to calm your anxiety, but now you’re experiencing that frustrating ‘wired but tired’ feeling. Despite its reputation as a calming adaptogen, ashwagandha sometimes produces contradictory effects that leave users confused and wondering if they’re doing something wrong. If you’re finding yourself wide awake at 3 AM or feeling strangely restless after taking a supplement meant to relax you, you’re not alone.

At Klarity Health, we’ve worked with many patients seeking natural solutions for anxiety who have experienced the ashwagandha paradox. This comprehensive guide will explore why these paradoxical reactions occur, how to adjust your regimen, and when to consider alternatives.

Free consultations available with select providers only.

Get a free consultation

And find an affordable, caring specialist.

Find a provider

Free consultations available with select providers only.

The Science Behind Adaptogen Paradoxical Reactions

Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) belongs to a class of herbs called adaptogens, which theoretically help the body resist various stressors. However, its complex biochemistry affects everyone differently.

Why Your Calming Supplement Might Be Causing Restlessness

Adaptogens work by modulating your body’s stress response systems, particularly the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis. For some individuals, this modulation can trigger unexpected reactions:

1. Cortisol Regulation: Ashwagandha can lower cortisol levels, which is beneficial for many people with anxiety. However, some individuals with adrenal fatigue or irregular cortisol patterns may experience disruption to their already compromised stress hormone cycles.

2. Thyroid Stimulation: Research suggests ashwagandha may boost thyroid function, which could potentially create that ‘wired’ feeling in some people.

3. GABA Receptor Activity: Ashwagandha affects GABA receptors in the brain, similar to anti-anxiety medications, but individual neurochemistry varies significantly.

The ‘Wired But Tired’ Phenomenon

This contradictory state—feeling simultaneously exhausted yet unable to relax—often occurs when supplements impact multiple body systems at once. Your nervous system might be calmed while your hormonal system is stimulated, creating an internal tug-of-war.

Optimizing Ashwagandha Dosage and Timing

Many paradoxical reactions can be addressed by adjusting how you take ashwagandha.

Finding Your Ideal Dosage

Withanolides—the active compounds in ashwagandha—vary significantly between products. Higher concentrations aren’t always better:

• Start Low: Begin with approximately 300mg of a standardized extract (containing about 5% withanolides)
• Gradual Increase: Add 150-300mg every few days until finding your sweet spot
• Less Can Be More: Some people respond better to lower withanolide levels (300-600mg daily versus the often-recommended 1000-1500mg)

Timing Matters: Morning vs. Evening Dosing

The timing of your ashwagandha dose can dramatically affect your experience:

• Morning Dosing: May provide daytime anxiety relief without affecting sleep
• Split Dosing: Taking smaller amounts twice daily helps maintain steady levels
• Evening Alternatives: If ashwagandha disrupts your sleep, consider switching to morning-only dosing

If you’re experiencing 3 AM wakings (a surprisingly common complaint), this typically signals cortisol dysregulation that might be exacerbated by evening doses.

Quality Matters: Not All Ashwagandha Products Are Equal

The supplement industry remains largely unregulated, creating significant variation between products.

What To Look For In Quality Ashwagandha

• Standardized Extracts: Products standardized to a specific withanolide percentage (typically 2.5-5%) ensure consistent potency
• Root-Only Extracts: Some products use leaves, which contain different compounds and may produce different effects
• Third-Party Testing: Certifications from USP, NSF, or other independent organizations
• Full-Spectrum vs. Isolated Compounds: Full-spectrum extracts contain all the plant’s compounds in natural ratios, which may work better for some people

Beyond Ashwagandha: Comprehensive Anxiety Management

When ashwagandha produces mixed results, a more holistic approach may be necessary.

Adaptogen Alternatives Worth Considering

If ashwagandha isn’t your ideal match, consider these alternatives that may offer anxiety relief with different mechanisms:

• L-Theanine: Promotes relaxation without sedation
• Magnolia Bark: Contains compounds that bind to anxiety-reducing receptors
• Holy Basil: Another adaptogen with a different phytochemical profile
• Lemon Balm: Mild GABA-boosting properties without the stimulating effects

Integrated Approaches That Go Beyond Supplements

At Klarity Health, we’ve found that combining appropriate supplements with other approaches often produces the best outcomes:

• Targeted Therapy: Brief interventions like cognitive behavioral therapy provide skills that supplements alone cannot
• Sleep Hygiene: Implementing consistent sleep routines can reduce the impact of supplement-related sleep disruption
• Breathwork and Meditation: These practices enhance the body’s natural stress response systems
• Professional Guidance: Working with healthcare providers who understand both conventional and natural approaches

When To Seek Professional Help

While experimenting with natural supplements can be empowering, certain situations warrant professional guidance:

• Persistent Paradoxical Reactions: When adjustments don’t resolve contradictory effects
• Worsening Anxiety: If symptoms intensify rather than improve
• Interactions with Medications: Ashwagandha may interact with thyroid medications, immunosuppressants, and some sedatives
• Underlying Health Conditions: Thyroid disorders or adrenal issues may be exacerbated by certain adaptogens

Klarity Health offers convenient telehealth consultations with providers who understand both conventional and integrative approaches to anxiety management. With transparent pricing and both insurance and cash-pay options, getting expert guidance on your supplement regimen is more accessible than ever.

Finding Your Personal Balance

Your experience with ashwagandha—whether positive, negative, or mixed—provides valuable information about your unique biochemistry. Many patients find that the path to effective natural anxiety management involves some trial and error, but this process becomes more efficient with informed guidance.

By understanding the science behind adaptogen paradoxical reactions, optimizing your dosage and timing, choosing quality products, and integrating complementary approaches, you can develop an anxiety management strategy that truly works for your individual needs.

Remember that experiencing side effects doesn’t mean you’ve failed or that natural approaches won’t work for you—it simply means your optimal solution may look different than expected.

FAQ About Ashwagandha Side Effects

Why do I wake up at 3 AM after taking ashwagandha?

This common reaction typically relates to cortisol regulation. Ashwagandha can alter your natural cortisol rhythm, potentially causing early morning awakening. Switching to morning dosing often resolves this issue.

Can ashwagandha make anxiety worse?

Yes, some individuals experience increased anxiety or restlessness due to ashwagandha’s effects on thyroid function and cortisol levels. This doesn’t happen to everyone but is a recognized paradoxical reaction.

How long do ashwagandha side effects last?

Most side effects diminish within 1-2 weeks as your body adjusts. Persistent side effects suggest you may need to adjust dosage, timing, or consider alternatives.

Should I stop taking ashwagandha if I experience side effects?

Gradual reduction is preferable to sudden discontinuation, as some people experience rebound anxiety with abrupt stopping. Consulting with a healthcare provider about tapering is recommended.